Esports Casters Call for Change After Embark Studios Replaces Talent With AI in The Finals Video
· GlobeWire Daily Editorial Desk · Source: www.ign.com

Image: IGN · Photo source · Resized and letterboxed to 16:9; no AI generation
Embark Studios faced widespread backlash from the esports community after replacing real-life tournament casters with AI commentators in a highlight reel for *The Finals*. The developer subsequently removed the video and canceled planned regional recaps.
The Controversy and Community Response
The controversy began when an official highlight reel for the APAC Closed Qualifiers of *The Finals* Grand Major was posted to social media. Instead of featuring the audio of the human casters who worked the matches, the video used the game's fictional AI commentators, Scotty and June.
Community casters quickly expressed anger and frustration online:
- Proto / Kai noted the extensive effort put into tournaments only to be replaced by AI that repeated their quotes.
- Bluepanda highlighted years of dedication followed by feeling undervalued or dismissed.
- LemonKiwi and Damascus criticized the move as harmful to human talent and indicative of a negative industry trend toward automated content.
Developer Apology and Canceled Plans
Following the global backlash, Embark Studios removed the video and issued an apology. Oscar Lundberg, representing competitive experience and community at Embark, admitted the omission of human talent was a mistake.
The company confirmed the following steps:
- The original APAC recap video was taken down.
- Planned AMER and EMEA recaps using the same AI format will not be released.
- The studio is rethinking its approach across all three regions.
Broader Implications and Industry Calls for Action
Casters affected by the situation have pointed to broader concerns regarding the use of generative AI in competitive gaming. While Embark previously utilized paid voice actors for the underlying technology of characters Scotty and June under contracted terms, commentators argued that substituting human tournament analysis with AI threatens the livelihoods of broadcast talent.
In response to the incident, community members have discussed potential protective measures, including industry-wide standards or collective organization to safeguard the roles of casters, producers, and production teams.
Practical Implications and Verification
- Verify Official Channels: Check *The Finals* official social media channels and statements from Embark Studios for direct updates regarding future broadcast plans.
- Monitor Industry Standards: Follow ongoing discussions within competitive gaming communities regarding AI usage policies and talent contracts.
AI-assisted reporting; source claims are attributed and have not been independently verified.



