Government Schemes

Biffa Appeals £51m Claim Over Failed Scottish Deposit Return Scheme

· GlobeWire Daily Public Services Desk · Source: www.bbc.co.uk

2 min read

Key takeawaysWaste management firm Biffa is pursuing an appeal in the Court of Session regarding its rejected £51.4 million claim against the Scottish government. The legal dispute stems from the collapse of a planned deposit return scheme (DRS) for bottles and cans, which was shelved in 2023 following regulatory disagreements between the Scottish and UK governments.
Biffa Appeals £51m Claim Over Failed Scottish Deposit Return Scheme

Image: BBC News · Photo source · Resized and letterboxed to 16:9; no AI generation

Waste management firm Biffa is pursuing an appeal in the Court of Session regarding its rejected £51.4 million claim against the Scottish government. The legal dispute stems from the collapse of a planned deposit return scheme (DRS) for bottles and cans, which was shelved in 2023 following regulatory disagreements between the Scottish and UK governments.

Background to the Dispute

Biffa served as the lead logistics partner for the proposed scheme. The company contends that a 2022 letter from then-minister Lorna Slater provided an "unwavering" commitment to the project, which they argue was a negligent misrepresentation. Biffa asserts that the government failed to disclose the significant risks associated with internal market rules, characterizing the minister's communication as a "half-truth."

  • Biffa’s Position: The firm argues that the original judge, Lord Sandison, made errors in law when he dismissed the initial claim in January, describing it as "wishful thinking." Biffa maintains that the government owed them a duty of care and that they were misled prior to signing the contract.
  • Government’s Position: The Scottish government maintains that the appeal points are irrelevant. Its legal team argues that Biffa was aware of the external risks, had secured insurance against potential delays, and did not view the minister’s letter as a guarantee of legislative success.

Future Context

A separate UK-wide deposit return scheme is currently scheduled to be implemented in October 2027. The Court of Session is expected to issue a written judgment on the appeal at a later date. Interested parties can monitor the official Scottish Courts and Tribunals website for future procedural updates.

Share this article
Read the original source: Waste firm appeals over £51m recycling scheme damages claim

AI-assisted reporting; source claims are attributed and have not been independently verified.

About the author

GlobeWire Daily Public Services Desk — AI-assisted news based on attributed published sources.

More to read