Danny Masterson Loses Appeal Against Rape Conviction and 30-Year Prison Sentence
· GlobeWire Daily Entertainment Desk · Source: www.theguardian.com

Image: the Guardian · Photo source · Resized and letterboxed to 16:9; no AI generation
Danny Masterson, best known for his role in That ’70s Show, has lost his appeal against his 2023 rape conviction, leaving his 30-year prison sentence upheld. A three-judge panel in the California court of appeal rejected his arguments, which included claims that the trial judge was biased against Scientology and that the court improperly handled church doctrine.
Masterson was convicted in 2023 of two counts of rape committed in 2003 against two women who were fellow Scientologists at the time. A third charge relating to a 2001 allegation was quashed. Throughout the proceedings, Masterson maintained that the encounters were consensual.
Court Ruling and Scientology Evidence
In an 89-page ruling filed on Tuesday, the three-judge panel addressed Masterson's claims regarding trial fairness. They found that the statements made by Los Angeles superior court judge Charlaine F. Olmedo during the trial demonstrated no animus or departure from neutrality regarding Scientology.
- Expert Testimony: The trial featured testimony from a former Scientologist regarding church practices concerning law enforcement.
- Constitutional Arguments: The appeals panel ruled that the jury was not asked to evaluate the truth of Scientology doctrine and that admitting evidence regarding the church did not violate the First Amendment.
- Additional Claims: The panel also dismissed arguments concerning the statute of limitations, evidentiary rulings, and the adequacy of the defense.
Prosecution Arguments and Church Response
Prosecutors during the trial argued that Masterson utilized his prominent position within the church to evade accountability. Testimony from accusers indicated they delayed reporting the assaults due to fears of violating internal church rules against contacting law enforcement and facing subsequent retaliation, such as ethics programs or shunning.
Following the appeal decision, Masterson’s defense attorneys, Cliff Gardner and Eric Multhaup, characterized the outcome as an unfortunate decision and stated plans to appeal to the California supreme court. The Church of Scientology previously issued a statement denying any policy discouraging members from reporting criminal conduct to law enforcement and calling trial descriptions of its beliefs false.
Practical Implications and Verification
- Legal Status: The 30-year prison sentence remains in effect while defense counsel pursues further appeals.
- Verification: The complete 89-page ruling can be accessed through official California court of appeal records.
- Support Resources: Confidential help is available globally for individuals affected by sexual assault, including RAINN in the US (800-656-4673), Rape Crisis in the UK (0808 500 2222), and 1800RESPECT in Australia (1800 737 732).
AI-assisted reporting; source claims are attributed and have not been independently verified.



