Ferries Boss Says Ferguson Shipyard Should Not Get New CalMac Contracts
· GlobeWire Daily World Desk · Source: www.bbc.co.uk

Image: BBC News · Photo source · Resized and letterboxed to 16:9; no AI generation
Kevin Hobbs, chief executive of Scotland's state-owned ferries procurement agency CMAL, told MSPs that directly awarding new CalMac ferry contracts to the nationalised Ferguson shipyard is "not the right thing to do." Speaking before Holyrood's transport committee, Hobbs stated that he and the CMAL board were completely opposed to giving the yard new work for two small electric ferries intended for the Sound of Harris and Sound of Barra.
Hobbs cited previous delays and overspends during the construction of the MV Glen Sannox and MV Glen Rosa, expressing concern that these problems could be repeated. He noted that while he wants the Port Glasgow shipyard to survive, building ferries there is not currently the right choice for island communities and argued that CMAL should instead pursue an open international tendering process. He also suggested that a direct award is currently unlawful, though it might become possible next year due to planned governance changes.
Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn defended the government's stance at the same committee session, stating that ministers remain committed to directly awarding the contracts to Ferguson Marine. Flynn expressed strong confidence in the yard's ability to deliver, emphasizing the importance of supporting the last commercial shipbuilder on the Clyde to ensure network resilience for island communities.
Ferguson Marine chief executive Graeme Thomson defended the yard, stating that it has a long and proud history, new leadership, and a skilled workforce that has learned hard lessons from previous programmes. Meanwhile, trade unions including the GMB criticized Hobbs' remarks, arguing that the workforce is blameless and that CMAL shares responsibility for past difficulties due to complex dual-fuel propulsion specifications and procurement processes.
Key Issues and Background
- Procurement Controversy: CMAL leadership opposes direct awards due to past overspends and delays, favoring open tendering.
- Government Position: Scottish ministers maintain that direct awards are necessary to support local shipbuilding and island resilience.
- Vessel Performance: Discussions at the committee also touched upon challenges with liquefied natural gas (LNG) propulsion systems on newly delivered vessels.
Verification and Next Steps
- Interested readers can review official committee proceedings and published letters via the Scottish Parliament and Transport Scotland websites.
- Further updates regarding the Small Vessels Replacement Programme and governance changes are expected from Scottish ministers.
AI-assisted reporting; source claims are attributed and have not been independently verified.



