Police officer in tears admits errors in fatal crash missing person inquiry
· GlobeWire Daily World Desk · Source: www.bbc.co.uk

Image: BBC News · Photo source · Resized and letterboxed to 16:9; no AI generation
A Gwent Police officer broke down in tears during a misconduct hearing while admitting errors in her risk assessment and log entries related to a missing person inquiry, before a crashed car carrying five people was found in St Mellons, Cardiff, in March 2023. Eve Smith, Rafel Jeanne, and Darcy Ross died in the crash, while Sophie Russon and Shane Loughlin survived. The three women had been reported missing to Gwent Police on 4 March 2023.
PC Lauren Livingstone, who is facing gross misconduct allegations alongside PC Richard Hardwick, gave evidence before the panel. Livingstone stated she could not remember whether home searches had been carried out for Sophie Russon or Eve Smith. Stephen Morley, representing Gwent Police's professional standards department, alleged that an entry written by Livingstone regarding a visit to Smith's house was misleading and dishonest. Livingstone rejected the allegation of dishonesty, acknowledging that the log was poorly written but maintaining she could not remember if searches had taken place.
Hearing Details and Evidence
- Officer Status: PC Lauren Livingstone was in her probation period during the 2023 investigation, having joined Gwent Police in October 2021 after a policing degree and a year as a special constable.
- Risk Assessment: Livingstone answered "no" when asked if Eve Smith's disappearance was out of character, citing that they appeared to be at a party and had stayed out late, though she later conceded she should have answered differently.
- Misconduct Allegations: Both Livingstone and Richard Hardwick face gross misconduct allegations. Hardwick appeared before the panel and denied the allegations against him.
During the hearing, Livingstone became emotional and stated she could not have foreseen the outcome, adding that she had not acted to lie or hurt anyone. She learned of the fatal crash the following day while working a night shift.
If gross misconduct is proven, the officers could face dismissal without notice. The hearing was adjourned for the panel to consider its findings.
Practical Implications and Verification
- Readers can follow updates on police misconduct panels through official Gwent Police or Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) announcements.
- Details of the proceedings are documented through official disciplinary tribunals and accredited reporting.
AI-assisted reporting; source claims are attributed and have not been independently verified.



