Earthshot Prize Faces Scrutiny Over Mumbai Venue Choice
· GlobeWire Daily Climate Desk · Source: www.theguardian.com

Image: the Guardian · Photo source · Resized and letterboxed to 16:9; no AI generation
The Earthshot Prize, an environmental initiative founded by the Prince of Wales, is facing criticism from conservationists regarding its choice of venue for the upcoming annual awards ceremony. The event is scheduled to take place on 17 November at the Jio World Convention Centre in Mumbai, a facility owned by the Reliance Industries conglomerate.
Concerns Raised by Conservationists
Critics have highlighted that Reliance Industries is linked to significant fossil fuel operations, including the operation of the world's largest oil refinery in Jamnagar. Furthermore, the conglomerate’s philanthropic branch operates Vantara, a massive private zoo. Organizations like the Wildlife Animal Protection Forum South Africa have expressed concern that hosting the prize at a Reliance-owned site could provide undue environmental prestige to a company under scrutiny by the global conservation community.
Wildlife Trade and Cites Oversight
Conservation groups have questioned the sourcing and rapid acquisition of animals at Vantara. The UN-backed Cites committee, which regulates trade in endangered species, has requested further reports from India regarding its import procedures for protected species. Specifically, the committee is reviewing 11 cases involving unresolved questions about the origins of animals currently at the Vantara facility.
Earthshot Prize Stance
In response to the criticism, an Earthshot Prize spokesperson stated:
- The venue was chosen based on technical infrastructure, capacity for large-scale international events, and practical logistical requirements.
- The organization is paying the standard commercial rental rate and did not enter into a philanthropic partnership with the venue owners.
- The prize aims to spotlight environmental progress in India, a critical region for climate solutions.
Vantara’s Position
Representatives for Vantara have denied allegations of wildlife trafficking, asserting that their mission is to rescue and rehabilitate distressed animals. The organization has previously been cleared of illegal acquisition allegations by India’s supreme court. They maintain that their breeding programs for endangered species serve as a modern conservation effort, though critics like Susan Cheyne of the IUCN note that the long-term conservation benefits of such models remain unproven.
Verification of these events can be conducted via official communications from the Earthshot Prize or public reports issued by the Cites Secretariat regarding ongoing compliance procedures.
AI-assisted reporting; source claims are attributed and have not been independently verified.



