Election Commissioners' Complaint Against Officer Manish Garg Remained Unaddressed by Secretariat
· GlobeWire Daily World Desk · Source: www.inextlive.com

Image: inextlive · Photo source · Resized and letterboxed to 16:9; no AI generation
Overview of the Complaint
According to information obtained through an RTI, two Election Commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, formally wrote to Cabinet Secretary TV Somanathan expressing concerns regarding the conduct of Deputy Election Commissioner Manish Garg. Despite these letters, the Cabinet Secretariat did not initiate action against the official.
The Dispute
On July 29, 2024, Commissioners Sandhu and Joshi raised objections regarding an order issued by Garg. Key points include:
- Unauthorized Changes: Garg allegedly redistributed work portfolios among senior officers without consulting the Election Commission or the affected officials.
- Operational Concerns: There were fears that the order might centralize authority over electoral roll updates, potentially undermining the role of state-level officials.
- Implementation: On September 26, the Election Commission stated that the contested work distribution order was ultimately not implemented following directions from the two commissioners.
Secretariat's Stance
The Cabinet Secretariat justified its decision not to intervene by citing the constitutional independence of the Election Commission. The Secretariat maintained that:
- The letters from individual commissioners did not constitute a formal, collective complaint from the entire Election Commission.
- Direct intervention by the executive branch could be interpreted as interference in the functioning of a constitutional body.
- It was suggested that the commissioners should ensure such communications are sent via the office of the Chief Election Commissioner to be considered official.
Profile of the Official
Manish Garg is a 1996-batch IAS officer from the Himachal Pradesh cadre. He assumed the role of Deputy Election Commissioner on September 2, 2024, having previously served as the Chief Electoral Officer of Himachal Pradesh. His tenure has faced scrutiny regarding the management of IT systems for voter lists.
AI-assisted reporting; source claims are attributed and have not been independently verified.



