Madhya Pradesh High Court Acquits Former Patwari in 30-Year-Old Bribery Case
· GlobeWire Daily World Desk · Source: www.livehindustan.com

Image: www.livehindustan.com · Photo source · Resized and letterboxed to 16:9; no AI generation
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has upheld the acquittal of a former 'Patwari' (revenue official) in a 30-year-old bribery case, dismissing an appeal filed by the state government. The incident dates back to October 17, 1996, when Munna Lal, then posted in the Khurai area of Sagar district, was allegedly caught by the Lokayukta while accepting a bribe of Rs 300 in exchange for issuing land records. Following a trial, the district court acquitted the accused in December 1997. The state government challenged this verdict in the Jabalpur High Court in 1998.
Key Findings of the High Court
- Lack of Evidence: Justice Sanjay S. Kalgaonkar noted that the prosecution failed to prove that the money was demanded or accepted as an illegal gratification.
- Flawed Recording: The court observed that the original recording of the alleged bribe demand was not verified in the trial court. Additionally, the accused's voice was not identified, and the integrity of the recording remained unproven.
- Alternative Explanation: Evidence suggested the Rs 300 recovered could have been a repayment for outstanding government dues of Rs 325 owed by the complainant, Veer Singh.
- Contradictory Statements: The court highlighted significant discrepancies in the complainant’s testimony, including inconsistent claims regarding the amount demanded (varying between Rs 450 and Rs 500 on different occasions) and the presence of witnesses during the alleged demand.
The court emphasized that the mere recovery of money and a positive 'phenolphthalein test' are insufficient to establish a bribery charge without corroborating proof of an illegal demand. Consequently, the High Court affirmed the lower court's decision, dismissing the government's appeal.
AI-assisted reporting; source claims are attributed and have not been independently verified.



