No 'Valid Case' to Reduce Number of Police Forces in Wales, Says Former Commissioner
· GlobeWire Daily World Desk · Source: www.bbc.co.uk

Image: BBC Cymru Fyw · Photo source · Resized and letterboxed to 16:9; no AI generation
Former North Wales Police and Crime Commissioner, Winston Roddick KC, has stated that there is no valid argument for consolidating Wales' four police forces into a single entity. His comments arrive amidst a broader debate regarding the modernization of policing in England and Wales.
Current Reform Proposals
Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley has warned that police forces across England and Wales must modernize or risk severe failure. A government white paper, published in January 2026, considers boundary reforms, with suggestions to reduce the current 43 police forces down to 8-10 regional units. The Home Secretary recently announced plans to create approximately 200 local districts, each led by a specific senior officer, aimed at keeping police closer to local communities.
Concerns Over Consolidation
Winston Roddick KC expressed strong opposition to merging the Welsh forces, arguing it would worsen efficiency and lead to "serious consequences." He highlighted the geographical challenges of covering the entirety of Wales under one command structure.
Gareth Pritchard, a former deputy chief constable of North Wales Police, echoed concerns regarding the efficacy of such drastic changes. He noted that there is no guarantee that reducing the number of forces would improve performance, discipline, or community accountability. While he acknowledges the need for modernization, he emphasizes that organizational restructuring is not a total solution for current policing pressures.
The Call for Devolution
The Welsh Government continues to advocate for the devolution of policing and justice powers. Dyfed-Powys Police and Crime Commissioner, Dafydd Llywelyn, supported this stance, suggesting that any upcoming changes in governance represent a "golden opportunity" for devolution. Prime Minister Andy Burnham has indicated he is open to discussions on the matter, while the Welsh Government maintains that reforms must prioritize local accountability and safety.
- Proposed boundary changes are expected to be published in January within the Police Reform Bill.
- Discussions regarding the restructuring are anticipated to continue over the coming months.
AI-assisted reporting; source claims are attributed and have not been independently verified.



